Whats with all the Winry hate

This is an essa for Full Metal Alchemist Winry, NOT Full Metal Brotherhood Winry.

I have heard how Winry is, a 'slut'  'whiney' and 'selfish'

WINRY IS A SLUT

Okay, tell me how is Winry a slut? Because she dosen't where a shirt sometimes. So what, loads of people don't where shirts, does that make them sluts? Does she walk up to Edward ans say, "Ohhhhh Edward, I want you in my bed," then get it on with him, only to go get it one with another male? No Winry does not do that. She is not a slut in any way, shape or form.

The only one that comes close to being a slut is Lust. She has shown to like men quite a bit, but only uses them to get what she wants, and she dress more sluty than Winry does, and her name sugests it to. Lust means, Sexual desire.

WINRY IS WHINEY

How is she whiney? She doesn't have fits everytime she doesn't get her way. She hardly ever pouts. She does get mad and Edward and Al for not keeping in contact and for keeping her in the dark, which it understandable. Yes, she crys at times, but that just show that she is human with emotions, but Winry doesn't let her emotions run her life or her way of thinking. Yes she cried when Edward and Al, you know left the world forever, I'm sure you get sad when a friend moves, it the same thing only They will NEVER see each other again, and they don't have FaceBook or Myspace to keep in contact, so it's pretty sad.

WINRY IS SELFISH

How so? She make autometal for Edward, gives Edward and Al a room and bed to sleep in, food to eat, and trys her best to help him. How the hell is that selfish? Yes, she makes him pay for the autometal, but thats business for you. And She gives him discounts. If she was selfish she would make him pay more than what she makes the other costomers pay, make him sleep outside, and make him find his own food.

WINRY IS A MARY-SUE

The prototypical Mary Sue is an original female character in a fanfic who obviously serves as an idealized version of the author mainly for the purpose of Wish Fulfillment. She's exotically beautiful, often having an unusual hair or eye color, and has a similarly cool and exotic name. She's exceptionally talented in an implausibly wide variety of areas, and may possess skills that are rare or nonexistent in the canon setting. She also lacks any realistic, or at least story-relevant, character flaws — either that or her "flaws" are obviously meant to be endearing.

"In other words, the term "Mary Sue" is generally slapped on a character who is important in the story, possesses unusual physical traits, and has an irrelevantly over-skilled or over-idealized nature."

Winry has blue eyes (the most common eye color) and blond hair (the most common hair color), she is not in a fanfic, she has a rare name but I don't thing it would classify as cool and exotic, just a prtty name. She's not exceptionally talented, as she makes mistakes, nor does she possess skills that are rare or nonexistent, infact Edward is the one who possess skills that are rare or nonexistent. And She's not exotically beautiful.

So she's not nessicerly a Mary-Sue.


WIRNY IS MOVING IN ON 'MY' EDWARD

This has got to be the stupidest reason to hate Winry that I have EVER herd. First off, Edward is NOT real, you CANNOT date him, marry him, f*ck him or have kids with him. You will NEVER be able to get together with a damn cartoon/anime character. Edward is NOT yours and will never be yours, no matter how many fanfictions you make, pictures of you and him getting cozey, or how much you dream of it, it will NEVER happen. EVER EVER EVER!!!

Do got it clear that you will not get to gether with Edward? I hope so, cause if not, you need to get some real help.

I even saw a picture of Edward killing Winry so he could get together with the person that drew the picture, and another that the artest was killing Winry so she could get to gether with Edward.... wow. You would seriously go that far. And they say Hitler was insane. Anyone who would draw a picture of a person being killed because of a reason like that is dangerous and needs to be put in a mentle insitution. If that artest was to get a real crush on a real person and then them get together with another, I'd hate to see her reaction.

I have a crush on a boy right now and he just so happens to have a girlfriend, do I want him to kill her? No. Do I want to kill her? No. Do I want her to be in any kind of pain or suffering in any way, shape, or form? No. I just want her to treat him good, and for them to be happy. You see, I don't have a mental illness, so I don't go bat-shit crazy over little things. But the one big difference between my crush and the fangirls lust for Edward is....Stay with me..... my crush is real. He is a real, living, breathing, flesh -n- blood human.

Hows this Anti Winry fans? You have your parents get murdered in a war, two of your childhood friends go way for years and only visit once in a while, get kidnapped by a crazy serial killer, then have you best friends and true love cross a magic door in the sky only to NEVER see you again in your life. After all that happens to you, then I will shut up, but only after all of the above happens to you.


FunFact: If Edward was a real person he would be over 100 years old. He was born in 1900 and it is 2011. He would be 111. Do you fangirls really want to date an old wrinkly 111 year old man? If so, you need more help than I thought, and thats alota help.